"Children will not remember you for the material thing you provided but for the feeling that you cherished them." Richard L. Evans
CORRUPTION,
CORRUPTION OR GREED? CHARITIES THAT ARE NOT SO CHARITABLE 50 WAYS TO LAUGH AT THE ELECTORATE MONSIGNOR MAURICE DOOLEY - PENCHANT FOR BREAKING THE LAW 'BERTIE BANKED THE MONEY' - HE SAYS TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY RIGHT OF PLACE/SECOND CHANCE AISLINN CENTRE SURVIVOR GROUP LEADERS ONLY SUPPORTING THEMSELVES Chapters 3 to 7
CORRUPTION OR GREED?
AN
ENEMY WITHIN
Seamus Walsh, a Fianna Fail and Oughterardbased councilor in Galway, (almost always Fianna Fail)charges other councilors €245 each to attend one of his
short conferences. Councilors can claim this money plus hotel and mileage costs
as well to attend. These expenses often reach €700 per seminar to have a good
old chat with the self confessed “highly educated” Seamus.Seamus is a partner in Esperenza
Enterprises and called one of these seminars the rather hypocriticaltitle of: ‘Local Government: Ethics in
public life, your responsibility’.It covers too ‘effective communications’ or ‘how to talk your way out of
anything’. When asked about tax payers money meant for the old, disabled, the
sick, and the starving, this is what Seamus Walsh said:
‘The councilor is the poorest, lowest paid. We do not get
five grand a year.
Is it because I am a councilor that I have to starve? I am a
fully fledged Christian. I’m not a blessed virgin but not a seasoned whore
either; (This is a hidden clue; think
Ivor Calley and Pairic Flynn ) Once they register (the councilors) I am
entitled to the fee”
By his own admission that he is an unseasoned whore, non-
virgin and fully fledged Christian, it seems he has a lot to learn about ethics
yet. Earning over a staggering €77,000 between 2008 and 2009 in expenses alone,
he is in no danger of starving anytime soon. This money does not include what
he has earned from Uadaras na Gaeltachta and other sources.
What some of these tax payer funded conferences or seminars for
councilors covered as well was
‘how to claim all their entitlements’ and ways to boost their personal vote in
local elections. The former was actually its working title. Here are a few more
expenses claimed by other ethic driven councilors: Two brothers claimed
€110,000 in iust one year; another councilor spent €88,000 on conferences fees
and mileage; one claimed expenses plus a night in a hotel just 25 miles from
her home; Two more took a €12,388 trip to the United States for St Patricks
day; Twelve more enjoyed a €20,000 trip to Tennessee,USA; Others still did not
bother to turn up at conferences despite thousands of euro in taxpayers money paid
out for non-attendance fees. Even those councilors not re-elected get over €70,000
for taking the trouble to represent us.
Seamus Walsh also
said in his rather shrill and very poor defense: “They are trying to cast me as some kind of Hitler”.Aside from the physical similarities I
never got his comparison with a mass murderer. Maybe Sean, communicator’ and ethics teacher, can explain it
to me. Cicero, ethical philosopher
and Roman statesman, explained it better in 42 BC:
“A nation can survive its fools and even the ambitious but
not treason from within. An enemy at the gates is less formidable for he is
known and carries his banner openly. But the traitor moves against those within
the gates freely, his sly whispers rustling through the alleys, heard in the
very halls of Government itself. He appears not as a traitor and speaks in
accents familiar to his victims and wears their face and their arguments; he
appeals to the baseness that lies deep in the hearts of men. He rots the soul
of a nation. He works secretly and unknown in the night to undermine the
pillars of a city and infects the body politic so that it can no longer resist.
A murderer is less to fear.”
In the meantime, I await a reply from Seamus about
unfinished potholes, feared pensioners, and those with disabilities who have
been muted by their fears.
Barry
CliffordOughterardGalway10
august 2010
Bank of Ireland executive Ritchie Boucher; cost the Irish taxpayer€1,900,000 that included €1,500,000 in bailout money last year.
This year, so angry was the Government with him that they made him the boss of the same bank to teach him a lesson, and gave him a salary of €623,000 plus a pension of €367,000. Failed banker, Boucher, wryly commented, "My pension neededto be funded".
Taxpayers will also have to fork €220,000every year to support Charles McGreevy’s pensions;
Mary Robinson will get over €200,000
Mary McAleese over €200,000
Fail to answer, Bertie Ahernover €200,000 plus a limoand two full time drivers so he will not need a little help from his friends again
Barry Clifford
Oughterard
Co. Galway
Mobile: 087 751 1113
FIANNA FAIL'S FIFTY WAYS TO LAUGH AT VOTERS
1. In October 2007, Taoiseach Bertie Ahern became the highest paid Prime Minister in the democratic world at €310,000, more than US President George Bush at €279,000. Fianna Fail Ministers such as Willie O’Dea are paid more than US Vice President Dick Cheney.
2. In October 2007, former Fianna Fail Government Press Secretary Frank Dunlop told the Mahon Tribunal that property developer Owen O’Callaghan paid off a debt of £10,700 for Fianna Fail councillor Colm McGrath when he was facing a court judgment.
3. In October 2007, a book was published that included a claim that a serving Government Minister has admitted taking cocaine, and that he wasn’t the only one doing it. Taoiseach Bertie Ahern has made no effort to investigate this.
4. In September 2007, Fianna Fail TD Michael Collins was found guilty in court of obtaining a tax clearance certificate under false pretences. He had previously made a €130,000 tax settlement arising from a bogus non-resident bank account.
5. In September 2007, jailed Fianna Fail councillor Michael ‘Stroke’ Fahey had missed six months of council meetings, and by law he should have been deemed to have resigned. He escaped this by asking the council to deem his absence to be ‘due to illness and attendance in Dublin’.
6. In September 2007, Taoiseach Bertie Ahern, while being questioned at the Mahon Tribunal, accepted that his earlier story that Celia Larkin had made a £30,000 sterling transaction on his behalf could not be correct, unless the bank records were inaccurate.
7. In September 2007, Taoiseach Bertie Ahern, while being questioned at the Mahon Tribunal, said that he must have given £30,000 to somebody else (to make a transaction that the bank had no record for), but he didn’t know who he gave the money to.
8. In August 2007, Bertie Ahern appointed as a Senator former Fianna Fail TD Ivor Callely, who had just lost his Dail seat in a general election, and who had resigned as a Junior Minister after a scandal in 2005.
9. In August 2007, Bertie Ahern appointed as a Senator former Fianna Fail TD John Ellis, who had just lost his Dail seat in a general election, and who had resigned as chair of an Oireachtas committee after a scandal in 1999.
10. In August 2007, it was revealed that Fianna Fail-led Governments have so far spent €52 million on obtaining and storing electronic voting machines that have only been used once, in a number of constituencies in the 2002.
11. In July 2007, after a strenuous seven days of work since being elected in mid-June, the Dail adjourned for a three-month summer holiday.
12. In July 2007 the Standards in Public Office Commission said that Fianna Fail had failed to report a donation in the party’s statutory declarations for 2005.
13. In June 2007, Taoiseach Bertie Ahern made secret deals, using taxpayers money, with independent TDs to secure their support as Taoiseach. Two of these independent TDs, Beverly Flynn and MichaelLowry, had previously been forced to resign from their parties after scandals.
14. In June 2007, Fianna Fail changed the law to create three new Junior Ministers with salaries of €150,000 a year. They had previously done this in 1977 and 1980. When Fine Gael did the same in 1995, Fianna Fail called it an abuse of the taxpayer and an act of hypocrisy, and Bertie Ahern vowed to abolish the new posts.
15. In March 2007, Fianna Fail councillor Michael ‘Stroke’ Fahey was jailed for twelve months after being found guilty of defrauding his own council of €15,000 and falsely implicating an innocent contractor in the crime. The jailed councillor was also chairman of the Limerick Prison visiting committee.
16. In May 2007, stockbroker Padraic O’Connor said that Bertie Ahern was wrong to say that he had given Ahern £5,000 as a loan from a friend in 1993. O’Connor said he was not a friend of Ahern’s, that he had been asked for a political donation of £5,000, that he had given that on a company cheque, and that he had been given in return a false invoice for consultancy work that had not been done.
17. In February 2007, Taoiseach Bertie Ahern praised the Moriarty Tribunal for its ‘outstanding work in painstakingly stripping away the layers of secrecy and obscurity surrounding Mr Haughey’s financial affairs and exposing them to public scrutiny.’
18. In December 2006, the Moriarty Tribunal found that former Taoiseach Charles Haughey took payments of €11.56 million, or €45 million in today’s money, between 1979 and 1996, and granted favours in return.
19. In October 2006, it emerged that Taoiseach Bertie Ahern had bought his house from businessman Michael Wall, who had been at a dinner in Manchester at which Ahern was given £8,000 sterling. When asked why he had not previously said that Wall was at the dinner, Ahern replied that Wall had not eaten the dinner.
20. In September 2006, Taoiseach Bertie Ahern said that, when he was Minister for Finance, he had unexpectedly received a donation of £8,000 sterling from some millionaires who he had a meal with in Manchester on the night before a Manchester United football match.
21. In September 2006, Taoiseach Bertie Ahern accepted that he had appointed people who gave him money to State boards, but he insisted that he did not appoint them because they gave him money. He said he had appointed them because they were his friends.
22. In September 2006, Taoiseach Bertie Ahern said that he had accepted £39,000 from friends, including the brilliantly-named Paddy the Plasterer, in 1993 and 1994. He said it was loans, and that he had tried to pay them back but they had all refused.
23. In September 2006, when Taoiseach Bertie Ahern was first asked about allegations of receiving from €50,000 and €100,000 from businessmen, he told journalists that a lot of the report was correct but that ‘the figures are off the wall.’ This, of course, was true, because he got some of the money ‘off Michael Wall’.
24. In June 2006, Taoiseach Bertie Ahern said at the funeral of Charles Haughey that: ‘He was a consummate politician… The definition of a patriot is someone who devotes all their energy to the betterment of their countrymen. Charles Haughey was a patriot to his finger tips.’
25. In May 2006, Fianna Fail Junior Minister Conor Lenihan heckled Socialist Party TD Joe Higgins during a Dail debate. Higgins had been campaigning on behalf of immigrant Turkish construction workers, and Lenihan said that Higgins ‘should stick with the kebabs’.
26. In December 2005, Fianna Fail Junior Minister Ivor Callely resigned when it emerged that a top construction company had painted his house free of charge, while the company was also doing work for the Eastern Health Board of which Callely was chairperson.
27. In November 2005, with gangland crime all over the newspapers, Fianna Fail Minister for Defence Willie O’Dea posed for photographers smiling as he pointed a pistol directly into the camera.
28. In April 2005, former Fianna Fail Junior Minister for Transport, Jim McDaid, who had led an anti-drink-driving campaign, was arrested after drunkenly driving his car the wrong way up a busy dual carriageway.
29. In January 2005, former Fianna Fail Justice Minister Ray Burke was jailed for six months for making false tax declarations, breaking a law that he himself had helped to pass. He served four and a half months in Arbour Hill prison.
30. In May 2004, Fianna Fail expelled Mayo TD Beverly Flynn from the Party. Bertie Ahern said the integrity of the party depended on her expulsion, that Fianna Fail was at a crossroads, and that the party would also have to deal with any other members who transgressed ethics and standards in public life.
31. In September 2003, Fianna Fail TD Michael Collins resigned from the Parliamentary Party after making a €130,000 tax settlement arising from a bogus non-resident bank account.
32. In September 2003, Fianna Fail TD GV Wright knocked down a nurse while driving under the influence of alcohol. The nurse’s leg was broken in four places.
33. In December 2002, former Fianna Fail Government Press Secretary Frank Dunlop told the Flood Tribunal that former Fianna Fail TD Liam Lawlor (who he also knew as ‘Mr Big’) was the first person to tell him that money would have to be paid to councillors in return for their votes.
34. In November 2002, former Fianna Fail Government press Secretary Frank Dunlop named six Fianna Fail councilors who he bribed to secure the rezoning of land at Carrickmines in south Dublin.
35. In September 2002, the Flood Tribunal found that former Fianna Fail Justice Minister Ray Burke received corrupt payments, including £125,000 from property developers and £30,000 from the owners of Century Radio.
36. In September 2002, the Flood Tribunal found that former Fianna Fail Government Press Secretary PJ Mara had failed to co-operate with the Tribunal, by failing to provide details of an overseas account. In the 1980s, in a Hot Press interview, Mara said that his greatest ambition was ‘never to be found out’.
37. In May 2002, former Fianna Fail Government press Secretary FrankDunlop said that he paid at least £160,000 to 25 councillors in relation to the redrafting of the Dublin County Council development plan from 1991 to 1993.
38. In February 2002, former Fianna Fail TD Liam Lawlor was jailed for a third time for contempt of court when he refused to comply with orders of the Flood Tribunal. When the Dail called for his resignation, he was brought to Leinster House in a prison van to speak against the motion. Lawlor had previously chaired the Dail Ethics Committee.
39. In January 2002, former Fianna Fail TD Liam Lawlor was jailed for a second time for contempt of court when he refused to comply with orders of the Flood Tribunal.
40. In December 2001, Fianna Fail TD Ned O’Keefe resigned as a Junior Minister. He had voted on a bill about feeding bonemeal to animals, forgetting to inform the Dail that his family was involved in manufacturing the substance.
41. In October 2001, Fianna Fail Junior Minister Joe Jacob, who was responsible for the Government’s emergency response to nuclear accidents at Sellafield, gave a comical interview on RTE radio that resulted in the Government having to send iodine tablets to every house in the country.
42. In April 2001, Fianna Fail TD Beverly Flynn resigned from the Oireachtas Public Accounts Committee. She had lost a libel case that she had taken against RTE, who had correctly reported that she had sold banking products designed to assist tax evaders. After losing the case, she faced a €2million legal bill.
43. In January 2001, former Fianna Fail TD Liam Lawlor was jailed for contempt of court when he refused to comply with orders of the Flood Tribunal.
44. In June 2000, Fianna Fail TD Liam Lawlor resigned from the Parliamentary Party after he misled an internal party investigation about a donation that he had received. Lawlor was also chair of the Oireachtas Joint Ethics committee.
45. In May 2000, Fianna Fail Finance Minister Charlie McCreevy nominated Hugh O’Flaherty to a £147,000 job as Vice President of the European Investment Bank. O’Flaherty was a former High Court judge who had been forced to resign after a scandal the previous year.
46. In February 2000, Fianna Fail TD Denis Foley resigned from the Parliamentary Party. He had £100,000 in an illegal offshore account. He said that he knew that his account might have been an Ansbacher one, but he had been ‘hoping against hope’ that it was not.
47. In November 1999, Fianna Fail TD John Ellis resigned as chairperson of the Oireachtas Agriculture Committee. He owed money to farmers, he had £250,000 in debts written off by NIB, and Charles Haughey had given him £26,000 of taxpayers cash to settle other debts.
48. In January 1999, former Fianna Fail Minister Padraig Flynn appeared on the Late Late Show on RTE. Now a European Commissioner, Flynn complained about the difficulties of living on ‘just £100,000 a year’ when he had three houses, housekeepers and various cars to maintain. ‘You should try it,’ he added.
49. In June 1995, Celia Larkin lodged £11,743.34 into Fianna Fail leader Bertie Ahern’s bank account. Ahern says that £10,000 sterling of this was actually his own money, part of £50,000 that he had earlier withdrawn from his own account and used to buy £30,000 sterling. However, the bank had no record of selling £30,000 sterling to anybody during that period.
50. In December 1994, Celia Larkin lodged IR£28,772.90 into Fianna Fail leader Bertie Ahern’s bank account. Ahern says that this was £30,000 sterling cash given to him in a briefcase by his soon-to-be landlord, just after he had become Fianna Fail leader and was expected to become Taoiseach. However, the amount equates exactly to $45,000 based on bank exchange rates on that date. source: IRELANDS DRUID SCHOOL
Mons. MAURICE DOOLEY - His Penchant for Breaking the Law
An expert in canon law insisted yesterday he would not report child sex abuse to gardai if a paedophile priest confided his crimes to him.
Monsignor Maurice Dooley was speaking in defence of under-pressure primate Cardinal Sean Brady after revelations he failed to alert gardai about the actions of the notorious paedophile priest Brendan Smyth when he learnt of them in 1975. Smyth would go on to abuse children for a further 18 years.
But Mgr Dooley, who studied canon law with Dr Brady, defended the cardinal's silence in 1975, and added that he would not necessarily refer sex crimes against children to gardai nowadays if passed information confidentially.
Mgr Dooley was asked what action he would take if a paedophile priest approached him now to confide his crimes.
"I would not tell anyone," he said. "That is his responsibility. I am considering only my responsibility. My responsibility is to maintain the confidentiality of information which I had been given under the contract of confidentiality.
"There must be somebody else aware of what he is up to, and he could be stopped. It is not my function."
"I would tell (the priest) to stop abusing children," he added.
Trust
"But I am not going to go to the police or social services in order to betray the trust he has put in me," said Mgr Dooley who was speaking on BBC Radio Ulster.
His comments contradict national guidelines for safeguarding children introduced by the Catholic Church early last year, whereby church authorities must ensure all allegations or suspicions of child abuse are promptly reported to civil authorities.
"What worries me is that while he may be coming out and saying this, how many other priests and bishops have the same opinion and would act in the same way?" abuse survivor Marie Collins told the Irish Independent.
Legal sources last night said that until 1997 it was a criminal offence not to report knowledge of a crime to the gardai, but that law had been knocked off the statute books without being replaced.
However, a new offence has been created under the Criminal Justice Act 2006 known as reckless endangerment of children, whereby a person having authority for a child can be prosecuted for intentionally or recklessly endangering a child.
The source added that a person could also perhaps be prosecuted for impeding the course of justice but this would only occur 'if gardai were already investigating the matter'.
The Garda Press Office refused to comment on the matter last night.
Jason O'Brien March 18 2010
IRELAND: BERTIE SAYS HE BANKED BRITISH MONEY
Wednesday, June 04, 2008
By Shawn Pogatchnik, Associated press writer
Dublin, Ireland former Prime Minister, who recently resigned amid questions over secret payments in the 1990s, told a corruption tribunal Wednesday that British money he deposited into bank accounts in 1994 was his own, and much of it came from gambling.
Bertie Ahern had previously denied depositing British pounds into the accounts. He resigned a month ago amid incessant questions over tens of thousands of dollars he secretly received from business friends in Ireland and England in the early to mid-1990s.
Ahern, who denies doing anything wrong, was Ireland's finance minister and treasurer of the country's long-dominant Fianna Fail party during that period.
A judicial investigation established by Ahern's own government in 1997 has spent years trying to trace the various sources of money supplied to Ahern, who insists he granted no political favors in exchange for cash gifts and unpaid loans.
When Ahern last appeared on the witness stand in February, he testified that he hadn't deposited any British money in 1994 - the year he began using bank accounts again. But investigators told Ahern the following month they had found bank records showing he deposited thousands of pounds in 1994.
Ahern admitted Wednesday he did arrange to have an office secretary put that money into Dublin bank accounts belonging to both him and his two daughters. He said he previously thought he had spent the British money while traveling or betting on horse races in Britain.
Ahern said he now believed the money represented cash he won gambling on horses as well as his own Irish political income that he had converted into British currency when he was considering buying an apartment in England.
The 11-year-old probe has already exposed several of Ahern's former colleagues in Fianna Fail as serial collectors of corrupt payments from businessmen.
Ahern was drawn into the investigation when a property developer accused him of receiving two payments from a rival developer in the early 1990s. Ahern denies those allegations.
Ahern began testifying in September. His testimony was widely mocked and disbelieved, undermining his long run of personal popularity.
The investigation seeks to establish the extent of political corruption, particularly involving land development, in Ireland from the 1970s to 1990s. Those caught by the tribunal have largely faced financial punishments for evading tax by failing to disclose their cash collections. But none has been successfully prosecuted for accepting bribes _ in part because Ireland had no effective laws regulating politicians' receipt of money until 1997.
PS: Connor Cruise O'Brien commenting on Ahern's former boss and prime minister, Charles Haughey, had said about him and the Fianna Fail party: "Grotesque, Unbelievable, Bizarre and Unprecedented" It was his summary for a scandal-plagued government of Fianna Fail chieftain Charles Haughey, one of O'Brien's perennial hate figures. He used an acronym to describe them as the GUBU party Barry Clifford
TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY
A Dublin Chamber of Commerce study in 2005 found that Irish business was losing €2 billion every year directly through economic crime. The combined economic cost of corruption is equivalent to the loss of 75,000 Irish jobs annually.
The Government has recently moved to treble the value of gifts and loans that politicians can keep without disclosing them. In addition, delays in introducing safeguards for whistleblowers and high fees for public information mean that Ireland is expected to sit in the third-tier of honest democracies for the time being, and for a long time to come.
A 2007 report by the economic think tank, the OECD, was heavily critical of the Irish government’s and businesses efforts to combat bribery. The Government in all of that most recent history is Fianna Fail.
Though corruption has always been rife and growing within Fianna Fail for decades, it was Eamon De Valera who told a senior minister in 1970 that Charles Haughey would ruin the party. One man alone would not do it for it made little difference until two decades plus later. By then corruption was the norm within the party.
In December 2006, the Moriarty Tribunal found that former Taoiseach Charles Haughey took payments of €11.56 million, or €45 million in today’s money, between 1979 and 1996, and granted favours in return.
Ray Burke was jailed for tax offences and feted in prison.
Frank Dunlop, Government press secretary, was jailed for bribing politicians among others.
Beverly Cooper Flynn had advised people to illegally evade taxes while working as a financial advisor for a bank.
Michael Collins had an offshore bank account to evade taxes.
Liam Lawlor was jailed for refusing to cooperate with a tribunal investigating corruption and was feted in prison.
Beverly Cooper Flynn had advised people to illegally evade taxes while working as a financial advisor for a bank.
Dennis Foley had an offshore bank account to evade taxes.
Michael Collins had an offshore bank account to evade taxes.
Ivor Callely had to resign his seat because of bribery charges.
Bertie Ahern's popularity actually increased when he was found to be wanting and contradictory in his evidence about alleged bribes given and received. He resigned under pressure with more questions than answers following his wake.
Padraig Flynn, father of Beverly, resigned his position as European Commissioner due to allegations of malpractice by the European Parliament.
In September 2007, Taoiseach Bertie Ahern, while being questioned at the Mahon Tribunal, said that he must have given £30,000 to somebody else (to make a transaction that the bank had no record for), but he didn’t know who he gave the money to.
In June 2007, Fianna Fail changed the law to create three new Junior Ministers with salaries of €150,000 a year. They had previously done this in 1977 and 1980. When Fine Gael did the same in 1995, Fianna Fail called it an abuse of the taxpayer and an act of hypocrisy, and Bertie Ahern vowed to abolish the new posts.
Bertie Ahern in September 2006, accepted that he had appointed people who gave him money to State boards, but he insisted that he did not appoint them because of that money. He said he had appointed them because they were his "friends."
Bertie Ahern, In September 2006, said that he had accepted £39,000 from 'friends', including a man named Paddy the Plasterer, in 1993 and 1994. He said it was loans, and that he had tried to pay them back but they had all refused.
A Fianna Fail Government Press Secretary PJ Mara, had failed to co-operate with the Flood Tribunal, by failing to provide details of an overseas account. In the 1980s, in a Hot Press interview, Mara said that his greatest ambition was "never to be found out."
In December 2001, Fianna Fail TD Ned O’Keefe resigned as a Junior Minister. He had voted on a bill about feeding bonemeal to animals, forgetting to inform the Dail that his family was involved in manufacturing the substance.
In May 2002, former Fianna Fail Government press Secretary Frank Dunlop said that he paid at least £160,000 to 25 councillors in relation to the redrafting of the Dublin County Council development plan from 1991 to 1993.
On and on it goes but why bore you to tears. The Country is now run by a prime minister of the same party as all of the above. He had bought shares in a mining company that he was about to give a licence to. When he was exposed, he sold the shares. He became Prime Minister by default because the last one, Bertie Ahern, resigned because he still has still those questions to answer.
Without mandate, this one has saddled the Irish taxpayer with billions of euro in loans to bail out his friends, the building developers and the banks. This man also believes that the child abuse scandals of the clergy in Ireland are church matters, and best left to them to deal with for he has enough problems running the country. His name is Brian Cowen
Him, his party, and the lack of transparency and accountability within it, are the problem!!!
Barry Clifford April 2010
RIGHT OF PLACE
The Irish Examiner Tuesday, March 09, 2010
Right of Place, one of the largest groups for victims of abuse, was ordered as a matter of urgency as far back as October 2009 to supply the HSE with in-depth details of the running of the charity, its finances and how many bank accounts and credit cards it had, among other things.
Right of Place is run by NOEL BARRY, a victim of abuse at the Rosminian school at Upton, Co Cork. In 2009, the HSE allocated the group €337,500 and the Department of Education gave it €75,331. Since 2002 it has collected more than €2.2m from the HSE, and the health board previously, and morethan €1m from the Department of Education. A further €88,000 was secured in National Lottery funding. In December, this paper revealed there were serious questions to be answered as to how money donated by religious orders and the Government had been spent.
Meanwhile, founder NOEL BARRY sought an injunction locking out a new committee formed by disgruntled members seeking to take control of the organisation. In a strongly worded letter to a new committee dated December 10, the HSE said it was "concerned and dismayed" at the situation and that clarity was urgently required. "Time and space afforded by the HSE to various elements within the organisation to resolve their differences must cease. No new service agreement can be considered until matters are resolved, and given the vulnerability of the client group the sooner the better," the letter stated. However, the Irish Examiner has learned that the HSE is currently providing a grant of €20,000 a month which, according to the HSE, is to cover the "pay and non-pay costs of the organisation". Sources within Right of Place membership have indicated that it seems as though the HSE is not interested in investigating how money was spent in the past, or having pertinent questions which members are asking answered. It is understood negotiations which had been ongoing with a HSE mediator between Mr Barry and a new committee have ceased. In a draft agreement seen by the Irish Examiner, the HSE is proposing to continue with the existing company and, according to the document, "legal disputes will be deemed settled on the signing of the agreement".
AISLINN CENTRE
Answers to questions that were asked of survivor groups and their leaders without mandate; Answers to questions that you were too polite to ask or did not know about; Answers to questions without mental reservations or mature reflection.
1. AHIA is a limited company that received €655,147 between 2006 and 2007 in Government funding that was meant to help you.
2. AHIA's Government funding does not include other contributions.
3. AHIA spent €655,147 of YOUR money in that year.
4. AHIA is a limited company.
I know, I know, who is AHIA. They have two directors: CHRISTINE BUCKLEY and CARMEL MCDONNELL-BYRNE, and are sometimes known as the AISLINN CENTRE. I am sure they can provide some of the answers to your questions too and if not, I will. Of course hear-say is no proof, so please ask for copies of all receipts and invoices as well.
In the meantime, NOEL BARRY of RIGHT OF PLACE in Cork, is on a diet after dining out on one too many plum bar and dinner grills of £264.55, and the Pope has relinquished his membership of the NAZI youth party after all these years citing his age as the main reason.
MICK WATERS has not sued me yet though I have sleepless nights.
JOHN KELLY is not speaking to him either though I cannot help wondering why.
BIFFO is still scratching his head for he does not know who is enemy or who is friend anymore.
BERTIE claims he does not even know the guy or anything else for that matter.
SUPPORT GROUPS WHO ONLY SUPPORT THEMSELVES (Part 3)
SOCA MEETING
Back in February in 2010, the meeting held by SOCA at liberty hall passed without anyone getting hurt unless the usual insults can be counted. The Clonmel Bellows was there doing what he usually does best, bellowing. Amazingly, he calls himself, The Right To Peace. It is a promise even he finds hard to keep. I was supposed to be there too but sent my ghost instead. They say the likeness was remarkable. There were other ghosts too and aside from the sixty people that did show up, the spirit world pushed that number to about one hundred and fifty. One lone reporter must have seen them too for that was what he reported.
The Clonmel Bellows denied the remark about Haiti, while another person remarked we should give the memorial money to two hospitals instead. It is worth reminding this is your money too we are talking about. Any questions were rudely answered, while one member was told to ‘shut the fu… up’ and no one knows yet what happened to the €145,100 they received between 2006 and 2007 [Figures, courtesy of FOI] This is also your money.
If this meeting is indicative of others, then they have a lot more to answer for than I at first thought. There was a positive in that JOHN KELLY must be following this site and has learned something from it. This relates to trust funds in that we at last are on the same page about something, though his first motion of the meeting is the most dangerous of all and goes something like this: We the survivors give an updated mandate to our group representatives to act and negotiate on our behalf with the Government, Religious Orders, Church, and other interested parties in indemnifying all survivors for the injustice which was inflicted upon them as children.
If the average board consists of five members acting for ten groups and they have been mandated mainly by cronyism alone, then we have fifty strangers acting for almost fifteen thousand survivors without mandate, integrity or transparency. This all about you too!
SUPPORT GROUPS WHO ONLY SUPPORT THEMSELVES (Part 4)
Soca of Ireland has as its secretary Mick Waters who lives in England. He is also the director of Soca in England.
Here in Ireland, SOCA or Survivors Of Child Abuse Limited had an official address of their registered office at 52, Parnell Square West which later became 95, Capel St Dublin 1.That place was sponsored separately by the HSE from the Education board. Mr. Waters home though is: 18, King Edward Road. Coventry. The company here does not have any capital. The total income of the company has derived from its past and present principal activity wholly undertaken in Ireland. It is registered as a charity, and its number is: chy16633.
Income for 2006 was €40,000 with administrative expenses of €42,578 leaving just €2,578 for income tax purposes ,leaving him with a tax bill of zero. After auditors fee it is left with a deficit of 2,420.
The following year Income for 2007 shot up to €105,100 with an administrative expense bill of €105,945. This left Soca with a surplus of €I155 not accounting for the accountant.
There was no stated employees or rent outlay for buildings for either of the above years, and apart for very minor expenses this is all income for somebody. Cash in the bank went from a high in 2006 of €699 to a low in 2007 of €525 and just like you I am still wondering where has all the money gone.
Now Mick, you can have a very public platform on my site to explain all of the above and while you are explaining all of that, with proof of course, I must forewarn you there is much worse to come.
In any disclaimer at the end of the year that has to be signed by those who present their accounts to the accountant, which absolves him of any responsibility, the final document does not come with the devil in the detail. That detail can run to thousand of receipts depending on what was spent. It is the only proof in any court or reception that finally matters to convince other of its integrity. Whether that was for luxury of Turkish Baths or the pampering at a Hilton Hotel.
SUPPORT GROUPS WHO ONLY SUPPORT THEMSELVES (Part 5)
AISLINN CENTRE
The latest explanation by Aislinn to Governments questions as to where all the money has gone, goes something like this:
The years before 2004, the auditors could not find, verify or stand over any accounts, so they do not count. Any funding admitted to for that period was €110,420.00 [presumably from the HSE] was advanced only to Christine Buckley, and her fellow director of the Aislinn Centre, otherwise know as AHIA.
The rest of those years except for 2005, show no proof of expenditure, or proof of expenses ending in 2008. What is proven, that for the years after 2004, the AISHLING CENTRE received from the HSE, [otherwise known as the Government] a further €1,475,985.00.
Yes, that is one million, four hundred and seventy five thousand euro, nine hundred and eighty five euro, and zero cents.
No information, or more importantly, proof has been provided as to the nature, or extent of services provided [except 2005] for which funding was given. It is a statutory requirement of law that you keep proper books of accounts. On this point, AHIA claims they are being discriminated against by the Government.
Notes: In the end of the year accounts of any business you sign a disclaimer form which absolves the accountant of any liability for error or omissions. It is in a sense considered hearsay evidence given in part or full by his client to him. Only when this evidence is backed by invoices, receipts, and other proofs. does he at anytime accept this as proof himself. That is of course if we are talking about a man. In this case we are. The following is his final summary of AHIA accounts:
"What is clear from the accounts is that for two years, and for part of a third year, money received could only be reported as having being advanced to directors. It is possible that this money was channeled to previously existing organizations and used in their work. Otherwise it is hard to see how the expenditure could have been justified, as the company had no other staff or premises. Whether a similar situation existed for the rest of the periods of accounts from 2003 to 2008, it is not possible to say from the information given in these accounts."
Nial Mc Gahon, Consultants. A S M HORWATH
In any limited paternal loyalty to any client, as much as it can be just short of lying, the above figures and commentary are his, and can be found again under the Freedom of Information act.
PS: The above does not include monies that may have been given from other quarters like religious orders or private individuals.
SUPPORT GROUPS WHO ONLY SUPPORT THEMSELVES (Part 6)
SOCA OF IRELAND
Soca of Ireland has as its secretary MICK WATERS who lives in England. He is also the director of Soca in England.
Here in Ireland, SOCA or Survivors Of Child Abuse Limited had an official address of their registered office at 52, Parnell Square West which later became 95, Capel St Dublin 1.That place was sponsored separately by the HSE from the Education board. MICK WATERS' home though is: 18, King Edward Road. Coventry. The company here does not have any capital. The total income of the company has derived from its past and present principal activity wholly undertaken in Ireland. It is registered as a charity, and its number is: chy16633.
Answers will need to be given regarding Avoca House when the Fraud Squad investigate these shenanigans.
Income for 2006 was €40,000 with administrative expenses of €42,578 leaving just €2,578 for income tax purposes ,leaving him with a tax bill of zero. After auditors fee it is left with a deficit of 2,420 euro.
The following year Income for 2007 shot up to €105,100 with an administrative expense bill of €105,945. This left Soca with a surplus of €I155 not accounting for the accountant.
There was no stated employees or rent outlay for buildings for either of the above years, and apart for very minor expenses this is all income for somebody. ANDREW BRENNAN of Dundalk is a registered Director (and yet he gripes on survivor sites about these group leaders. Beware the forked tongue of the enemy within). Cash in the bank went from a high in 2006 of €699 to a low in 2007 of €525 and just like you I am still wondering where has all the money gone.
Now Mick, you can have a very public platform on Paddy Doyle’s site to explain all of the above and while you are explaining all of that, with proof of course, I must forewarn you there is much worse to come.
In any disclaimer at the end of the year that has to be signed by those who present their accounts to the accountant, which absolves him of any responsibility, the final document does not come with the devil in the detail. That detail can run to thousand of receipts depending on what was spent. It is the only proof in any court or reception that finally matters to convince other of its integrity. Whether that was for luxury of Turkish Baths or the pampering at a Hilton Hotel.
SUPPORT GROUPS WHO ONLY SUPPORT THEMSELVES (Part 7)
On 15/06/02 VAL GROARKE and his good friend, NOEL BARRY both acting for Right Of Place in Ireland booked into an Inn in London, and it was not just any Inn. It was the four Star Hilton Olympia, one of the most prestigious hotels in the heart of that great city.
Tired after their journey while carrying the torch and burden of the Institutional Victims that they claimed to represent, which numbered over 15,000, they set down quickly to business over a few drinks. Then a few more, and a few more…… By now, the night and early morning had lost its first flush of youth and they were not so young either. They at last decided to retire to their shared room. Morning would wait a little later in the day.
When it did arrive the hangover that came with it dulled the senses a bit but not their appetite. They got dressed, and I presume showered and shaved, and headed down for the morning grill. Work of some importance may have been conducted around this time on the telephone and the food was good. So good in fact that the Hilton charged them £264.55. This was of no consequence to Val and Noel, after all were they not here to represent abuse victims, even though many of them had no breakfast at all that morning for they could not afford it. The real world waited outside for them but they did not seem to notice much for they were still nursing that hangover.
That evening, they had dinner brought to their room for they were burnt out with the trials of the day that weighed heavily on their shoulders. A few more telephone calls was all that was left in them to make. After whispering a few sweet nothings to each other while framed in the moonlight, sleep came fast and soundly that night. In the morning there was no time for breakfast and quickly paid for their very short stay. Noel, handed the cashier a Barclaycard after they handed him the bill. Neither showed surprise including Val when it came to £833.19 that included £32.14 for those important phone calls. After all, the government through the HSE, including some charitable priests, christian brothers and nuns were paying the bill anyway. They could not have known that these two support group leaders along with others, were only supporting themselves. The intervening years through inflation would have made this bill much higher and help pay for at least one of Paris Hilton’s handbags, and were only a fraction of the expenses for those 48 hours. With that, they all lived happily ever after.
These details will never be in the end of year breakdown for 2002, only the generic disclaimer form that allows any kind of ink but not for truth itself, and leaves the accountant to go home with a clean slate.